Allure Beauty Box vs. Boxycharm: Which Beauty Subscription Box Is Better?

Make the first comment!By Best Subscription Boxes. Last updated .
Hello Subscription has independently selected every item on this page - with thousands of subscriptions reviewed, we are subscription experts! Things you buy through our links may earn us a commission.
Go to comments

See our comparisons of these Beauty Subscription Boxes!

Allure Beauty Box vs. Boxycharm Comparison

Choosing the right beauty box for you can be, well, challenging. Whether you’re looking to spoil yourself a little or you just want to try beauty products from different brands, a monthly beauty subscription box is an amazing way to indulge oneself. But which one best matches your needs?

You’ve likely heard of Allure. Founded in 1991, Allure is an American women’s magazine solely focused on beauty that offers Allure Beauty Box as their monthly beauty subscription box. Allure Beauty Box has a unique product mix of beauty samples that are not usually included in other subscription boxes. From their expert-approved items of handpicked makeup and skincare products, each Allure Beauty Box serves a mix of luxury and indie brands. Allure Beauty Box subscribers can opt for an annual subscription to get a free Mega Bundle, which contains more products.

On the other hand, Boxycharm is another beauty subscription service, which was founded in 2013. Since then, they have grown to be one of the most well-known beauty subscription boxes on the market. From their customized box of full-size makeup, skincare, beauty tools, and color cosmetics, Boxycharm surprises you each month with products from popular and upcoming beauty brands. Boxycharm subscribers can upgrade to Boxycharm Premium or Boxycharm Luxe to receive more items. Note that the Boxycharm Luxe upgrade is exclusive to the Boxycharm subscription and is not yet made available for Boxycharm Premium members.

Allure Beauty Box

Image from our review.

Allure Beauty Box is a subscription service, which delivers 6 or more products (at least 3 full-size items) to your door each month. This includes expert-approved makeup and skincare products. All of their items are top-trending and hand-selected.

Sign up for the Allure Beauty Box and receive a FREE bonus gift!

Boxycharm

Image from our review.

Boxycharm is a monthly beauty subscription box. Each box comes with 5 full-size items featuring makeup, skincare, beauty tools, and color cosmetics. Every Boxycharm package aims to bring trending products to subscribers.

Get a FREE Gift with Boxycharm – enter code on site! Just get the coupon here and use this link to subscribe.

These beauty boxes offer quality items that fill all your beauty needs. Allure Beauty Box and Boxycharm are both packed with beauty products that you will look forward to receiving. However, there are still certain factors where Allure Beauty Box Box and Boxycharm differ from one another, which will help you take your pick. Here are all the details that will help you make your decision in choosing which option suits you better.

PRICING AND PLANS

Allure Beauty Box Pricing and Plans

If you consider budget as a part of your buying decision process when choosing the subscription box that’s right for you, Allure Beauty Box is the more affordable option. Allure Beauty Box promises a value of at least $100 per box. Even though both boxes offer lower monthly costs to subscribers who sign up for longer plans, Allure Beauty Box subscription boxes are still cheaper than Boxycharm. Allure Beauty Box’s monthly subscription plan costs $23 per box. Allure Beauty Box offers free shipping within the contiguous United States, and Canada has a shipping fee of $5.

Boxycharm Pricing and Plans

Although both give out savings to subscribers who sign up for longer-term subscriptions, Boxycharm is slightly pricier than Allure Beauty Box. Nonetheless, Boxycharm comes with the assurance of delivering an average value of over $175 per box. Boxycharm’s monthly subscription plan costs $25 per box. Boxycharm offers free shipping within the contiguous United States (48 bordering states), while Hawaii, Alaska, all U.S. territories, and Canada have a shipping fee of $5 per box.

In each of these beauty subscription boxes, subscribers get to save more money by acquiring multiple month subscription plans. Allure Beauty Box and Boxycharm both offer free shipping in the United States and provide discounts for longer commitments. Value-wise, both boxes give you more than what you pay for, but Allure Beauty Box’s subscription plans are still lower-cost.

CUSTOMIZATION AND SIGN UP PROCESS

In order to pick the right beauty subscription box for you, it must be one that matches your beauty needs. Allure Beauty Box lets you take a Skincare Routine Quiz to find the best products for your skin, while Boxycharm includes a Beauty Quiz that’ll help them tailor a box specific to your needs. Both subscriptions have a sign up process that is user-friendly and their steps are easy to follow.

Allure Beauty Box Customization and Sign Up Process

To join Allure Beauty Box, you’ll only have to accomplish a few quick, simple steps. Mainly, they’ll ask you to pick a subscription plan.

After you’ve finished reviewing your order details, you can place your order and become a member on the Allure Beauty Box website. In addition, Allure Beauty Box gives subscribers the option to take their Skincare Routine Quiz that’ll help them put together a customized regimen for you. They’ll ask you to provide information like your skin description, your skin concerns, and your preferred type of moisturizer and sunscreen.

Boxycharm Customization and Sign Up Process

To join Boxycharm, you’ll have to answer questions about yourself for them to get to know you a little better. Primarily, they’ll ask you to pick a subscription plan.

Once your order has been placed, you’ll be taken to the Boxycharm Beauty Quiz to help them get an idea of what you’re into. This quiz is basically insignificant and has little to do with the items that you’ll receive.

Finally, you can subscribe to Boxycharm’s exclusive email list for early sneak peeks, special promotions, and exciting giveaways. You can also sign up for their text message to receive free alerts for early sneak peeks and special promotions.

MONTHLY THEMES

Allure Beauty Box Monthly Themes

Even though Allure Beauty Box doesn’t have a stated theme each month, they do not repeat the products they send out. Thus, Allure Beauty Box subscribers can enjoy new items every month. Additionally, each box includes a mini-magazine with the list of the featured products, discount codes for a future purchase, how-to guides, and beauty tricks.

Boxycharm Monthly Themes

Boxycharm always has a theme each month, and their items serve fresh new looks every month. Boxycharm’s past boxes featured themes such as “Breaking The Ice,” “Festival Vibes,” “Mother Nature,” “Harvest,” “Fresh Start,” “Lucky,” and “Sweet Treats.” Their box contents also include tips related to the month’s theme, season, or holiday, which makes the unboxing experience for subscribers all the more enjoyable.

TYPES OF PRODUCTS AND BRANDS

Allure Beauty Box Types of Products and Brands

Every Allure Beauty Box aims to bring items that fit your lifestyle. Allure believes in the importance of using products that are tailored to your individual needs. Each box contains a mix of 6 or more editor-tested and curated products (at least 3 of which are full-size items) such as makeup, hair care, skincare, nail items, beauty tools, and so much more. Allure Beauty Box subscribers will receive a variation of products based on member history and will not receive the same product more than once. Despite not offering personalization with their products, Allure takes pride in their package contents that are carefully tested, reviewed, and approved by Allure editors themselves. One of the perks of Allure Beauty Box is subscribers get to benefit from the Allure editors’ beauty expertise and the top products they have access to.

With Allure Beauty Box, skincare products are greatly featured. The types of products you could expect from your Allure Beauty Box subscription commonly consist of skincare products, different kinds of lipsticks or lip care products, eye makeup, face makeup, hair care products, nail polish, and every now and then you’ll receive body care products, eyeshadow palettes, makeup brushes, beauty tools, or perfume. Some of the well-known brands you could get in your Allure Beauty Box include Nature Lab, Kate Somerville, Akar Skin, Tarte Cosmetics, Wander Beauty, Appeal Cosmetics, Olay, Belif, Rituals, Dr Botanicals, Floss Beauty, Mamonde, Purlisse, Eva NYC, Viktor & Rolf, Thrive Causemetics, Acure, Curology, Avarelle Cosmetics, Peach & Lily, Erno Lazlo, Pixi Beauty, Cleo Noir, Elemis, Verso Skincare, Sigma Beauty, NatureLab, Cetaphil, Mudmasky, Saturday Skin, U Beauty, and more.

In addition, Allure Beauty Box subscribers can get a free Mega Bundle or 12 products valued at over $315 with the purchase of an annual subscription (prepay $250 for 12 months and save $26 compared to monthly), which basically has a bunch of items included in their past boxes plus other products you haven’t gotten yet. This mostly comes with a mix of skincare products, different kinds of lipsticks or lip care products, hair care products, eye makeup, face makeup, body care products, and the occasional eyeshadow palettes, makeup brushes, beauty tools, brow makeup, nail polish, or perfume. Allure notes that the bundles may vary per customer, and yearly subscriptions are non-refundable.

Boxycharm Types of Products and Brands

All active Boxycharm subscribers have the power to choose at least 1 item, including 4 picks by Boxycharm out of the 5 full-size products for their upcoming boxes during the monthly Choice event. This comes with 5 full-size beauty items, which range from makeup and skincare, to beauty tools and color cosmetics. In order to be updated during the Choice event, you must regularly check your personalized Charmer Benefits calendar on the front page of Boxycharm’s website.

With Boxycharm, palettes are heavily featured. The types of products you could expect from your Boxycharm subscription typically consist of eyeshadow palettes, skincare products, different kinds of lipsticks or lip care products, face makeup, eye makeup, face palettes, and once in a while you’ll receive makeup brushes, beauty tools, brow makeup, nail polish, or perfume. Some of the popular brands you could get in your Boxycharm include Pretty Vulgar, Ciate London, Luxie Beauty, Becca, Grace & Stella, Trestique, Morphe, Trestique, GlamGlow, Milk Makeup, Farmacy, Laura Geller, Tarte Cosmetics, Natasha Denona, Earth Harbor, Jouer, OFRA, Saturday Skin, Too Faced, Fenty Beauty, Emma Hardie, Clarins, Marc Jacobs, Sunday Riley, MAC Cosmetics, Morphe x Manny MUA, Glow Recipe, Korres, NARS,  Dr. Brandt, Sutra Beauty, and more.

Additionally, if you’re a Boxycharm member with a monthly subscription plan, you can acquire the Boxycharm Luxe ($59.99 every 3 months and valued at up to $395) as a quarterly upgrade with 8-9 full-size items (2 of which may be chosen by you during the Choice event) from luxury brands and hand curated products that you will be billed prior to or during each quarterly shipping month. Boxycharm notes that Boxycharm Luxe is subject to availability, and it depends on your placement on the waitlist.

EXTRAS

Allure Beauty Box Extras

Each Allure Beauty Box serves top-trending, editor-tested makeup and beauty picks. Being a magazine, Allure Beauty Box also comes with a mini-magazine with the list of the featured products, the MSRP of the full-sized products and where to find them, discount codes for a future purchase, step-by-step guides for every product found in the box and editor tips on how to use them, and beauty tricks. Aside from having the option to acquire Allure Beauty Box’s yearly subscription with a free Mega Bundle or 12 products valued at over $315, new subscribers signing up for the first time will receive a new member gift valued at $15-plus as well. Allure Beauty Box subscribers will also have access to sneak peeks, members-only discounts, coupon codes, exclusive offers, events, and beauty tips. From time to time, Allure also runs flash promotions, referral rewards, and test promotions that are mailed directly to your associated email address. Just make sure you are opted in to Allure’s promotional emails in your account settings to be eligible for these special promotional events.

Boxycharm Extras

One of the most notable features of Boxycharm is they let you find new and creative ways to use their products by providing tutorials and looks shared by their Charmer community on social media. Besides having the option to acquire the quarterly upgrade to Boxy Luxe, Boxycharm also has a monthly add-ons event where amazing bonus beauty items that you didn’t choose during the Choice event nor receive in your box variation can be purchased at member-exclusive prices, except during Boxycharm PopUp months. Their add-ons will ship separately from your box, and it may take 1-3 shipments to complete your order. Boxycharm notes that these add-ons are available for a limited time each month and orders are made on a first-come, first-served basis. Additionally, Boxycharm subscribers can enjoy Boxycharm PopUp, which is their biggest shopping event that features beauty products at up to 80% off. The Boxycharm PopUp is exclusively available to active members and only happens every three months. However, the Charm Room where subscribers can redeem reward items using Charms temporarily closes during PopUp and add-ons events, and Charms cannot be applied to PopUp purchases.

LOYALTY AND REWARD PROGRAMS

Allure Beauty Box Loyalty and Reward Programs

Allure Beauty Box subscribers are offered free products for referring friends. You can earn increasing rewards (up to $54 value) the more friends you get to sign up using your unique referral link. Here are ways to earn rewards from Allure:

  • Refer 1 friend: Earn Viktor & Rolf Perfume ($24 value).
  • Refer 3 friends: Earn Flawless Finish Duo ($33 value).
  • Refer 6 friends: Earn Skin Detox Duo ($54 value).

Your referral gift will arrive 1-3 weeks after your friend’s first Allure Beauty Box has been shipped.

Boxycharm Loyalty and Reward Programs

Boxycharm refers to their points as “Charms,” and subscribers are offered rewards by shopping on their website, referring friends, and sending feedback on the products they send out. Here are ways to earn points from Boxycharm:

  • Keep your Boxycharm subscription: Earn 450 Charms for every three months of staying with their subscription service.
  • Refer your friends: Earn 500 Charms for each friend who signs up for Boxycharm through the referral link and/or code provided by them.
  • Review your Boxycharm: Earn 50 Charms for every product review or an overall box review.

You can redeem these Charms through the Charm Room for reward items offered on Boxycharm’s website that will be applied automatically upon checkout.

SKIPPING AND CANCELLING

Skipping and Cancelling for Allure Beauty Box

Allure customers with active subscription plans can suspend their service at any time to skip one or more boxes. You can reach out to Allure’s customer care to pause your subscription and select a restart date. You can also cancel your membership at any time by contacting Allure’s customer service via phone or email. However, the request to skip or cancel must be processed before the end of the previous month.

Skipping and Cancelling for Boxycharm

Boxycharm doesn’t allow its subscribers to skip their subscription. Even though your Boxycharm subscription renews automatically, you may cancel your membership through your account at any time without any charges.

CUSTOMER SERVICE

Allure Beauty Box Customer Service

Allure ensures that their customers would always have a good experience with any of their representatives. They give you the option to call them, email them at [email protected], or send them a direct message on Twitter @Allure regarding your specific concerns. Their team responds to all inquiries within 48 hours. 

Boxycharm Customer Service

Boxycharm aims to address all feedback, comments, requests for technical support, and other communications relating to their website. You may contact them at [email protected] regarding any concerns you may have.

SUMMARY

Here’s a quick overview of each box to help you decide better:

PRICING AND PLANS

  • If you value getting the most out of your subscription, Allure Beauty Box costs as low as $23 per month and $250 for the one-year subscription (each box is worth over $100). They also offer free shipping within the contiguous United States.
  • If you value getting the most out of your subscription, Boxycharm costs as low as $25 per month and $275 for the one-year subscription (each box is worth over $175). They also offer free shipping inside the contiguous 48 United States.

CUSTOMIZATION AND SIGN UP PROCESS

  • If you want to receive customized skincare products, Allure Beauty Box offers items tailored to your individual needs. Their sign up process is user-friendly and the steps are easy to follow.
  • If you want to receive customized beauty products, Boxycharm provides items aligned with your particular needs. Their sign up process is extremely detailed and and ensures to gather all the valuable information.

MONTHLY THEMES

  • If you like to experience a box without repeat products, Allure Beauty Box comes with a variation of items.
  • If you like to experience a box with contents that vary month to month, Boxycharm comes with themes each month.

TYPES OF PRODUCTS AND BRANDS

  • If you need a box that fits your lifestyle, Allure Beauty Box contains a mix of 6 or more editor-tested and curated products (at least 3 of which are full-size items) such as makeup, hair care, skincare, nail items, and beauty tools. Allure Beauty Box has partnered with high-end brands that’ll deliver luxurious items to your doorstep.
  • If you need a box according to your liking, Boxycharm contains 5 full-size beauty items, which range from makeup and skincare, to beauty tools and color cosmetics. Boxycharm features a lot of brands that’ll serve fresh new looks your way.

EXTRAS

  • If you want to take advantage of Allure Beauty Box’s benefits, their package contents include a mini-magazine with the list of the featured products as well as beauty tips and guides from Allure editors.
  • If you want to add bonus beauty items to your Boxycharm box, they offer add-ons that feature their amazing products.

LOYALTY AND REWARD PROGRAMS

  • If you love to earn free products, Allure Beauty Box provides reward items for subscribers that refer friends.
  • If you love to earn reward items, Boxycharm provides points or Charms for subscribers that shop on their website, refer friends, and send feedback on the products they send out.

SKIPPING AND CANCELLING

  • If you wish to skip or cancel your Allure Beauty Box subscription, you need to get in touch with Allure’s customer service, and process it before the end of the previous month.
  • If you wish to cancel your Boxycharm subscription, you can disable it through your account page. There is no option to skip their subscription plans.

CUSTOMER SERVICE

Still need more info?

What’s our pick – Allure Beauty Box or Boxycharm?

Overall, Allure Beauty Box and Boxycharm both offer products that are geared towards your tastes and preferences. For those who love surprises and want to receive luxurious beauty samples at an affordable price, Allure Beauty Box is probably the preferable choice. On the other hand, Boxycharm is for customers who want to experience popular and upcoming beauty brands.

Looking for more subscription box showdowns? See all our subscription box comparisons to help you find the best subscription for you!

Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

About Best Subscription Boxes

Want to see the very best subscription boxes? Check out the subscriptions selected by experts or see what readers voted on as the best subscriptions and boxes!