FabFitFun Fall 2025 Review: Fall Trends and Everyday Essentials

Is the FabFitFun Fall 2025 box still delivering everyday value and seasonal flair now that the price has gone up? With annual memberships now priced at $249.99 and seasonal subscriptions at $74.99, it’s fair to wonder whether the box still offers the blend of style, self-care, and function that longtime fans expect. This Fall 2025’s curation features a mix of trending accessories, practical lifestyle picks, and familiar beauty favorites. I got my hands on the latest box — let’s see how it stacks up in both quality and usefulness.

This box is still available! Check out the full spoilers and all the variations for the Fall 2025 FabFitFun Box here.

There are lots of item variations that are detailed below.

Customization 1

Subscribers will get to choose among the following:

• Mela Artisans Scalloped Edge Mango Wood Board ($100)
• amika forget frizz anti-frizz shampoo + conditioner bundle ($56)
• Nutrafol Skin Clear Skin Nutraceutical 1 Month Supply ($88 Value)
• Splits59 Gym Tote ($80 Value)
• ELEMIS Dynamic Resurfacing Facial Pads ($65 Value)
• Sunday Citizen Snug Lap Throw Cherry Lacquer ($68 Value)
• WEWOREWHAT Oversized Crewneck in S, M, L, XL, XXL, or XXXL ($68 Value)
• Noon & Moon Pie Dish in Cherry Lacquer OR Taupe ($65 Value)
• MESO Goods Helen White Candle Holder ($69 Value)
• LUXE CHOICE + $49: Solawave 4-in-1 Skincare Wand Kit ($207 Value)

I chose the Mela Artisans Scalloped Edge Mango Wood Board!

The Mela Artisans Scalloped Edge Mango Wood Board ($100) instantly stands out for its intricate scalloped edges and natural wood finish. While it’s priced at $100, the board is fairly compact and leans more decorative than functional. It’s great for serving cheeses or seasonal snacks during small gatherings, but not ideal for everyday kitchen prep. It’s a charming fall-inspired piece, though its value may feel inflated for casual use.

Customization 2

Subscribers will get to choose among the following:

• ILIA Lightshift Cream Highlighter in Glint OR Daze ($38)
• ILIA Sunshift Cream Bronzer in Eclipse, Ray, Rise OR Bask ($38)
• Nia Ariana Cardigan S/M, L/XL, or PLUS ($98)
• By Adina Eden Emerald Green CZ Baguette Earring & Necklace Combo Set ($110 Value)
• ELEMIS Pro-Collagen Marine Cream ($94 Value)
• First Aid Beauty Retinol Eye Cream ($44 Value)
• 8 Other Reasons Vegan Leather Slouchy Bucket Bag ($149)
• 8 Other Reasons Betsy Slouch Tote in Stone ($129)
• Noon & Moon Cherry Lacquer Set of 2 Mugs ($76)
• Oribe Serene Scalp Oil Control Dry Shampoo Powder ($46)
• Oribe Serene Scalp Oil Control Treatment Mist ($58)
• Iconic London Prep-Set-Glow in Original ($32)
• Playground Playdate Massager ($35 Value)

I have the 8 Other Reasons Vegan Leather Slouchy Bucket Bag!

Another lifestyle-forward inclusion is the 8 Other Reasons Vegan Leather Slouchy Bucket Bag ($149). The faux leather has a soft texture that gives it a relaxed, lived-in vibe that fits perfectly with fall layering and cozy aesthetics. That said, the lack of inner pockets makes it feel more fashion than function. It’s a solid seasonal accessory, but it may not suit everyone’s daily routine.

Customization 3

Subscribers will get to choose among the following:

• Dr. Jart Cicapair Tiger Grass Corrector 50ml SPF30 ($54)
• Glow Recipe Guava Vitamin C Dark Spot Serum ($45)
• Rare Beauty Soft Pinch Luminous Powder Blush in Cheer, Hope, Happy or Joy ($27)
• Electric Picks Camilla Necklace in Gold or Silver ($68)
• Modern Picnic Lunch Bag ($40 Value)
• Citrine Cream & Sugar Set + Talking Tables Pumpkin Salt & Pepper Shaker Bundle ($75 Value)
• Stoney Clover Lane Zipped Card Case ($48)
• Kerasilk Multi-Benefit Hair Oil ($35)
• Arrows Digital Offer: 3 months access to Arrows, a matchmaking platform ($297 Value)

Mine is the Electric Picks Camilla Necklace in Gold!

I got the Electric Picks Camilla Necklace, valued at $68, which came in either gold or silver. It’s a delicate, everyday piece that fits right into current minimalist jewelry trends and layers well with other pieces. The design is easy to wear, but it didn’t feel particularly unique or premium in weight. For those who appreciate subtle, on-trend accessories, it works — just don’t expect a showstopper.

Customization 4

Subscribers will get to choose among the following:

• Thrive Causemetics® Brilliant Eye Brightener™ in Stella ($26)
• Ceremonia Guava Leave-In Conditioner ($27)
• Thrive Causemetics® Liquid Brow™ Lamination Lifting Gel ($26)
• Darling Society Silicone Trivets Set of 3 ($30)
• Darling Society Cotton Napkin Set ($28)
• LUV AJ Seashell Threader Earring in Gold or Silver ($58)
• 8 Other Reasons Jewelry Travel Bag ($49.95)
• LIT Method Digital Offer Lit Method 6 Month Trial ($59.99)

I got the 8 Other Reasons Jewelry Travel Bag!

The 8 Other Reasons Jewelry Travel Bag ($49.95) was one of the more useful surprises in this box. Compact but well-organized, it offers enough compartments to neatly store rings, necklaces, and earrings without tangling. The exterior has a soft, stylish look, and the interior layout feels well thought out. Unlike other lifestyle extras in past boxes, this one feels genuinely helpful for both travel and home storage.

Customization 5

Annual Subscribers will get to choose among these items (and FFF will pick for everyone else):

• Rare Beauty Find Comfort Niacinamide Hydrating Hand Cream ($18)
• Pantone Notebook ($18.99 Value)
• BONDIBOOST Heat Protectant Spray ($22)
• Volition Chocolate Macadamia Hydrating Mask ($48)
• SKNBODY Hair Identifier Spray Bundle ($20.99)
• Splits59 Pilates Grip Sock in S/M or L/XL ($32 Value)
• BetterSleep Digital Offer: BetterSleep 4 months of the premium subscription ($39.99 Value)

I received the Pantone Notebook!

I ended up choosing the Pantone Notebook ($18.99 Value), thinking it would be a fun and useful addition for jotting down ideas or to-do lists. While the design is colorful and the branding is eye-catching, it turned out to be underwhelming in person. It’s slim, with average paper quality, and doesn’t feel like it belongs in a premium-priced box. Looking back, I probably should’ve picked something with more substance or everyday value.

Customization 6

Annual Subscribers will get to choose among these items (and FFF will pick for everyone else):

• Merit Shade Slick Tinted Lip Oil in Pink Beet OR Taupe ($24)
• Merit Signature Lip Lightweight Lipstick in Classic OR Maison ($26)
• XMONDO Hair Super Gloss Ultra-Frizz Defense Spray ($29)
• Steve Madden Mystie Sunglasses ($48)
• Noon & Moon Pie Server in Cherry Lacquer OR Taupe ($48)
• LUXE CHOICE + $28: Maison Louis Marie No.13 Nouvelle Vague Eau de Parfum ($98)
• Rare Beauty Find Comfort Body & Hair Fragrance Mist ($28 Value)
• Bloom Strawberry Kiwi Greens ($29.99 Value)

I received the Steve Madden Mystie Sunglasses!

Included in the mix are the Steve Madden Mystie Sunglasses ($48), which offer a chic yet safe design perfect for transitioning into fall. The tortoiseshell pattern feels seasonal, and the shape flatters most face types. However, the lightweight construction makes them feel slightly fragile, especially at this price point. They’re stylish enough for weekend wear but may not stand up to frequent use.

Customization 7

• Rare Beauty Find Comfort Niacinamide Hydrating Body Lotion ($28 Value)
• Hourglass Voyeur Eyeshadow Stick in Aurora, Phoenix, Galaxy, Prism, Solstice, or Moon ($34)
• The Nue Co. Magnesium Ease ($38 Value)
• Business & Pleasure Lauren’s Navy Stripe Apron ($79 Value)
• Amika Soulfood Nourishing Hair Mask ($36)

Mine is the Amika Soulfood Nourishing Hair Mask!

The Amika Soulfood Nourishing Hair Mask ($36) brings back a fan favorite in the beauty category. With its rich texture and salon-worthy scent, this mask softens and hydrates without weighing hair down — delivering results that long-time users will recognize. This product was included in Customization Category 7, a new addition for Fall 2025 that FabFitFun doesn’t typically offer. While the extra category adds more variety to the box, the value of this pick may feel underwhelming for seasoned subscribers who have received it in past seasons.

The FabFitFun Fall 2025 box delivers a curated mix of trend-forward accessories and practical lifestyle pieces that align well with the season. Items like the Mela Artisans scalloped wood board and the 8 Other Reasons slouchy bucket bag bring warm, autumnal textures and cozy hosting vibes, while the Amika Soulfood Hair Mask adds a self-care touch just in time for drier weather. The accessories like the Electric Picks necklace and Steve Madden sunglasses add style, though their value feels more subjective. While I appreciated the usefulness of the jewelry travel bag, the Pantone notebook fell flat for me. At nearly $75 per box, the new pricing does raise expectations — this curation offers variety and seasonal charm, but I felt that every pick felt premium enough to fully justify the cost. Altogether, the Fall 2025 box leans more lifestyle than beauty, offering everyday essentials with a touch of seasonal flair — but not every item feels equally essential.

FabFitFun is a seasonal subscription box that brings a touch of excitement and self-care to your doorstep. Priced at $79.99 per season, the FabFitFun Seasonal Subscription Box includes a curated selection of four full-size products, featuring a mix of premium and emerging brands. Some items are handpicked by the FabFitFun team, while others can be personalized to suit individual tastes. If you’re looking for a more immersive experience, the FabFitFun Annual Subscription Box, starting at $259.96, offers a premier option with six fully customizable full-size products. Annual subscribers enjoy perks like unlimited swap credits, faster shipping, and early access to the latest products. It’s a fun and convenient way to discover and enjoy a variety of lifestyle goodies each season. FabFitFun is also one of the best subscriptions for women.