Completing the Puzzle Review: Endless Entertainment with Hassle-Free Puzzle Rentals

Hello Subscription independently researches and reviews the best subscriptions and products. Things you buy through our links may earn us a commission.
Go to commentsNotification

Looking for a screen-free way to unwind and have fun? Let us introduce you to Completing the Puzzle, a puzzle rental subscription that’s all about delivering fresh, exciting challenges straight to your doorstep. With access to over 1,294 unique puzzles from a diverse catalog featuring 40+ brands, you’ll never run out of brain-teasing entertainment. What’s more, new puzzles are added weekly, ensuring there’s always something novel to tackle. Plus, by opting for puzzle rentals instead of purchases, you’re not just having fun, you’re also being sustainable—each puzzle is reused to minimize waste, and a portion of every sale goes towards planting trees.

I recently had the pleasure of trying out Completing the Puzzle, which launched in 2020, and it’s already become a highlight of my leisure time. I’ve explored both the 1 Puzzle Unlimited Plan and the Four Puzzle Plan. Alongside the puzzle itself, they send you a handy legend and a return label for when you’re done. For new subscribers, they even send a thoughtful welcome kit with a personal touch—a letter, stickers, and coasters. Intrigued? Keep scrolling for my full review!

1 Puzzle Unlimited Plan

Let’s dive into the 1 Puzzle Unlimited Plan! It’s perfect if you like taking things at your own pace. You’ll receive one puzzle at a time, but if you’re up for the challenge, you can complete 2 to 3 puzzles in a month. What’s great is that Completing the Puzzle recently upgraded their packaging for the 1 Puzzle Unlimited Plan from a poly mailer, which not only looks better but also align with their commitment to sustainability. It’s a small change, but it makes a big difference in everybody’s puzzling experience. Moreover, their 3-day guarantee ensures that even if you’re a bit farther away, the wait for your next puzzle fix is never too long.

When you sign up, you’ll get access to Completing the Puzzle’s customer login, a useful tool for personalizing your puzzle journey. You can create a wishlist of your dream puzzles, and if they’re available when your next shipment goes out, they’re in! Plus, browsing the catalog by piece type, count, themes, and brands makes finding the perfect puzzle a breeze. I love that I can tweak my puzzle preferences, switching up themes and difficulty levels whenever I want a new challenge. And managing my account details, like subscription dates and billing info, is super easy.

I was thrilled to unwrap Sweet Dreams, a puzzle from the brand Pezel, as part of my Casual Plan subscription. This particular puzzle stood out as one of their early access offerings, adding an extra layer of excitement to my puzzling experience. As I laid out the pieces, I was immediately struck by the puzzle’s vibrancy. Each piece seemed to burst with color, creating a captivating scene that drew me in from the start. The theme, centered around a delightful candy-filled world, sparked a sense of nostalgia and whimsy, transporting me to a place where sweet dreams truly do come to life. It was a joy to work on!

Four Puzzle Plan

Moving on to the Four Puzzle Plan, which comes in a sleek black box that’s not only stylish but also eco-friendly – talk about a win-win! This plan is perfect for avid puzzlers like me who crave a constant stream of challenges. In just one shipment, I’ve had the pleasure of diving into a variety of puzzles, from charming animal-themed designs to intricate landscapes that kept me captivated for hours. With four puzzles arriving every month, there’s always something fresh and exciting to anticipate. And if you ever find yourself hungry for more, you can easily speed up your deliveries and renewal dates to maintain that satisfying puzzling momentum.

Here’s a closer look at the reusable black box that arrived with my Four Puzzle Plan! Not only does it add a touch of elegance to the unboxing experience, but it’s also incredibly practical. Sturdy and spacious, it keeps my puzzles safe and organized until I’m ready to tackle them. Plus, knowing that it’s reusable makes me feel good about reducing waste. It’s the perfect way to receive my monthly puzzle fix – all neatly packaged and ready for me to enjoy.

Completing the Puzzle offers a delightful mix of puzzles, ranging from well-known brands to hidden gems. With this plan, I’ve had the pleasure of piecing together Happy Boy, featuring an adorable dog that kept me entertained with its 300 pieces, and Cats of the World, a must-try for feline fans with its 500 pieces of fun. Additionally, the scenic wonders of Spring Picnic and Spring Break at Clinque Terre have transported me to idyllic settings with their vibrant imagery and challenging pieces. In case you’re interested in a smaller selection, Completing the Puzzle also offers the Two Puzzle plan for those who prefer a more modest puzzle rotation.

Each puzzle I’ve received has been of high quality, with vibrant images and sturdy pieces that fit together perfectly. I’ve spent many enjoyable hours lost in the challenge of completing them. What really draws me to Completing the Puzzle is its practicality and sustainability. As someone who loves puzzles but doesn’t have the space to store them all, the rental model is a lifesaver. I can enjoy a new puzzle whenever I want without worrying about cluttering up my home or feeling guilty about contributing to waste. Plus, being able to return the puzzles once I’m done is incredibly convenient – no more collecting dust or taking up precious shelf space. Additionally, the fact that they sanitize the puzzles when you send them back adds an extra layer of reassurance, ensuring a clean and safe experience for every puzzler.

Completing the Puzzle provides a puzzle rental subscription service with flexible options to cater to every puzzle enthusiast’s preferences. The 1 Puzzle Unlimited Plan, featuring blue and yellow packaging, allows customers to enjoy one puzzle at a time, with the option to complete 2-3 puzzles per month. Prices start at $30 monthly, with discounts available for 3-month and 6-month subscriptions, priced at $87 and $168 respectively. For those craving more puzzles, the Two Puzzle plan offers two puzzles shipped together, starting at $50 per month, with discounts for 3-month and 6-month subscriptions priced at $144 and $282 respectively. Lastly, the Four Puzzle plan, packaged in a sleek black box, delivers four puzzles monthly, priced at $44 per month, with discounts available for 3-month and 6-month subscriptions at $126 and $240 respectively.


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

  • Billie Cater

    I love doing these puzzles, they be are good quality and the colors are vibrant.. The only thing is, I can’t stop myself and keep one going at all times!

  • Briana

    I love my completing the puzzle subscription! They’re so quick and the quality is fabulous. Any issue I ever had was resolved quickly. My whole family gets excited to see what puzzle we’ve gotten next!

  • Samantha P.

    I love this subscription! It was originally a gift from my boyfriend (now husband) and now it’s a weekly tradition for us to puzzle together. We’ve been members for over 2 years and love the variety of puzzles. Best idea ever!