Butcher Box Review: The Freshest Meat and Seafood Delivered Right to Your Door

Make the first comment!
Hello Subscription independently researches and reviews the best subscriptions and products. Things you buy through our links may earn us a commission.
Go to commentsNotification

Everything you need to know about Butcher Box, a meat and seafood subscription service.

Butcher Box Review

If you’re searching for a reliable source of beef, pork, chicken, and seafood, look no further! Butcher Box is a delivery subscription service offering premium meat and seafood. Say goodbye to the endless trips to butcher shops, fish markets, or your local grocery stores! With this subscription, you’ll receive a steady supply of proteins delivered conveniently to your home.

With the mission to make high-quality meat more accessible to all, Mike Salguero founded Butcher Box in 2015. The brand not only gives fair wages and support to partner farmers, ranchers, and fishermen who raise animals with sustainability in mind, but also raises the bar for the meat you serve to your family. It’s also a Certified B Corporation, which means it meets the highest standards for social and environmental impact, making it one of the best and most trusted meat and seafood sources out there.

My family of six has been raving about Butcher Box ever since! They always send us a variety of the highest quality beef, pork, chicken, and seafood. Butcher Box is committed to providing quality meats free of chemicals or antibiotics, which makes me feel so much better about feeding it to my family. I have practically everything I need to put great food on the table, from breakfast to lunch and dinner!

DEAL: Check for the latest special offer for Butcher Box! Use this link to get the deal.

Butcher Box Benefits & Drawbacks

Now, let’s look into the advantages and disadvantages of Butcher Box:

Butcher Box Benefits

  • High quality, sustainably-sourced meats, fish, and poultry
  • Flexible plans; several plan choices and box sizes available
  • Uses eco-friendly packaging
  • Convenience; delivered on your schedule with free shipping
  • Member perks, including For Life deals

Butcher Box Drawbacks

  • A bit expensive when compared to conventional meats
  • Takes up more freezer space since you’ll get a decent amount with every delivery
  • Limited seafood options
  • Not locally sourced

Butcher Box Review




Butcher Box delivers a selection of premium meat and seafood on your schedule. All protein cuts are humanely raised without antibiotics or added hormones! Subscribers can choose one of four curated boxes or opt for a custom box instead. Each box (Classic Box size or Big Box size) is filled with high-quality beef, pork, chicken, or seafood, flash-frozen for freshness, and vacuum-sealed to lock in flavor. You can also skip, pause, or cancel whenever you want, plus shipping is free!


My Butcher Box Review

We’ve been subscribers of Butcher Box since 2016, and we have enjoyed the service ever since. Whether it’s a curated box or a custom box we receive, my whole family has enjoyed the dishes I made with the meats and seafood from this subscription. Portioned in manageable sizes, it’s easy for me to thaw out just the right amount I need for cooking. The cuts are generous, the quality is superb, and the taste is inexplicably good! If you’re running out of ideas on what to cook, Butcher Box also posts recipes on their website. There are over a hundred recipes and videos for beef, pork, chicken, seafood, turkey, and more!

They give you the option to customize your own box or let them curate a box for you. You can also choose a box size to suit your family’s needs. They’re transparent and honest about where all of their protein cuts come from. Plus, they also have great member perks! You’ll get “For Life” bonus products when you subscribe to whichever plan you want. Not to mention, shipping is always free!

Look at this Curated Box with a huge variety of pork and beef cuts! For people who love to alternate between pork and beef for their daily protein consumption, this would be an ideal box.

High-quality meat cuts also make high-quality meals for the family. One thing we love about the pork and beef items we’ve tried from Butcher Box is that they are perfect for roasting or grilling. Since they are perfectly portioned, you can easily prepare the meats even on a busy day, and they make such a filling meal choice.

Oh, and for those who love making their own breakfast or brunch, there are many Butcher Box meat products to choose from! For instance, we’ve tried their Breakfast Sausage and it turned out really delicious. It has a great flavor, and you can make it even tastier with cheddar cheese and other seasonings.

Here’s another sample Curated box that contains only beef cuts! If you like having steak nights at home, you’d love their selection of beef cuts including NY Strip Steaks, Sirloin Cap, Flat Iron Steaks, Premium Steak Tips, and more.

A steakhouse-quality dinner is easy to achieve since we have these top-quality beef cuts from Butcher Box. You can save yourself from trips to the restaurant just to taste some delicious steak, and you’d always be ready for a cookout or honestly any celebration since you have an auto-delivery of the best beef cuts.

Sometimes, we crave international cuisine too – and Butcher Box still comes to the rescue! Top sirloin, for example, is excellent for making kebabs. The top sirloin steak we received from the subscription was lean and juicy, they were easy to cut into smaller pieces and put into the skewers! Served with yellow rice, this delicious meal is also quite filling.

Here’s another sample Curated box showing a selection of beef and chicken cuts! Cook them up in a stew or alternate between beef recipes and chicken recipes for your lunches and dinners, it’s totally up to you. You’ll receive versatile cuts, so your weekly menus will never be boring again.

Our roasted meats from this subscription service always turn out so tender. Even if you don’t have any sauces around, the full and rich flavor of the meat is already enough. That’s how you know it’s really great quality! Pictured above is Butcher Box’s Eye Round Roast, a boneless cut oozing with flavor (not fat). You can slice it thinly and use it for making sandwiches or simply pair it with your choice of sides as we did!

Butcher Box is known for its exceptional poultry offerings! Their commitment to quality shines through as they exclusively source free-range chickens. Our experience with Butcher Box poultry has been consistently positive – the products always arrive fresh and odor-free. These poultry items are ideal for preparing a speedy weekday meal, such as the drumsticks and wings featured in the image. You can pair them with your preferred sauce or glaze and complement them with your favorite sides, allowing for endless possibilities when creating a delicious chicken dinner.

Aside from meat lovers, Butcher Box also caters to seafood lovers who want to get their hands on their favorites! Some of the seafood products offered by the online delivery service are Cold Cracked Lobster, Wild-Caught Alaskan Sockeye Salmon, Cod, Salmon Burgers, and Wild-Caught Gulf Shrimp. We’ve had the opportunity to try their shrimps through the For A Year deal, and we couldn’t be more delighted. Pictured above is our sheet pan shrimp boil, coated and seasoned with butter and Old Bay for a richer flavor. Yum!

Of course, you can also get a Custom Box – great for families who have different preferences in meat cuts, or even just for home cooks who would like to choose specific cuts for their recipes. The box pictured above has a little bit of everything, from steaks to ground beef and even chicken!

Is Butcher Box Worth it?

There are two things worth noting about this subscription: quality and convenience. That alone made me love Butcher Box. As a busy parent, I prefer to do things in the most convenient way possible, which includes shopping for ingredients. It saves me a great deal of time compared to visiting butcher shops, fish markets, or local grocery stores. It lets you know where your meats come from, and how they’re raised and prepared. The subscription also supports fishermen, ranchers, and farmers who were given fair wages for their work, helping them improve their lives.

If you’re a conscious eater who wants to know exactly where your food comes from, then this subscription is for you. Everything they offer is humanely raised with no antibiotics or added hormones and is sustainably harvested and wild-caught. The whole subscription experience is simple and absolutely satisfying! In conclusion, Butcher Box is a great meat and seafood delivery service, and it’s trustworthy!

If you want to see similar services, check out our list of meat subscriptions and fish & seafood subscriptions.

All About Butcher Box

Butcher Box is all about “meat and seafood done the right way”. It’s a convenient way to stock up on premium meat and seafood or add proteins to your diet. This subscription is transparent on where their protein offerings are raised and sourced from. It will give you peace of mind knowing that their meats all come from reputable sources!

How does Butcher Box work?

Getting protein-filled boxes is easy with Butcher Box. You only need to choose a plan (Curated or Custom) and box size (Classic or Big) to start your subscription. After you’ve decided on a box, you may choose the specific cuts you want in your shipment (Custom) and add-ons. There are more than 25+ high-quality cuts to choose from, including 100% grass-fed and grass-finished beef, free-range and organic chicken, humanely raised pork, and wild-caught seafood.

Just provide them with your shipping and payment information to process the order. Your box will then be shipped in 1-2 days, with delivery expected within 8 business days. Prior to billing, you can adjust your box type and frequency if you wish to do so. You can also cancel, pause, or skip the subscription with no strings attached!

How much does Butcher Box cost?

The price for the Custom Box is slightly elevated from the Curated Box because it contains 20% more meat. Both plans provide you the option to select a box size: Classic or Big.

The Custom Classic Box costs $169, whereas the Custom Big Box costs $306. The Classic Box contains 9-14 lbs of meat, while the Big Box contains 18-26 lbs. It also comes with the option to change your meat selection monthly.

On the other hand, the Curated Box includes options for a Mixed Box, Beef & Pork Box, Beef & Chicken Box, or an All Beef Box. The Curated Classic Box ($146) includes 8-11 lbs of meat, while the Curated Big Box ($269) includes 16-22 lbs.

Classic boxes are ideal for individuals and small families, while Big boxes are good for mid-size families and large freezers. Boxes are delivered every 4 weeks, 6 weeks, or 8 weeks depending on your chosen frequency. Shipping is free!

Where can I buy Butcher Box?

All you have to do is visit Butcher Box’s website to start your subscription. Select a plan, then a box size, and you’re all set. Fill your box with the cuts you want (if you opt for a Custom Box) and add-ons, then provide them with the required information to process your subscription. It’s really a hassle-free way of getting high-quality meats and seafood to serve on the table without the need to step outside your home!

Where and how does Butcher Box ship?

Butcher Box ships to all 48 contiguous states. Currently, they don’t offer shipments to Alaska, Canada, Hawaii, and PO boxes. Once your order ships, you’ll receive an email notification with the tracking information, or visit the Order History on your account page to track your order.

How is Butcher Box packaged?

Butcher Box meat and seafood are flash-frozen for freshness and vacuum-sealed to lock in flavor. Everything is safely packaged and delivered straight to your door in an eco-friendly, 100% recyclable insulated box. They ship it out frozen solid and add dry ice to keep them frozen while in transit. All meat and seafood arrive ready to store in the freezer or thaw to use!

What products does Butcher Box sell?

There are more than 25 cuts offered to date, including beef, pork, chicken, and seafood. All proteins have zero antibiotics and zero added hormones ever!

The cattle used for beef cuts are 100% grass-fed, grass-finished, and humanely raised. The majority of the beef is sourced from Australia, where cattle are free to roam on grassy pastures throughout their lives. Protein cuts offered include sirloin strips, burgers ribeyes, and chuck roast.

The hogs used are also humanely raised without gestation or farrowing crates. They’re raised on pastures or in hoop barns and fed on a vegetarian diet. Pork cuts are sourced from pigs with heritage-breed lineage, including Duroc, Berkshire, and Chester White. You can get ground pork, boneless pork chops, pork tenderloin, and bacon, among other varieties.

There’s also free-range organic chicken raised without cages, crates, or crowding. They’re humanely raised as well, free of antibiotics or added hormones! Some cuts offered include whole chicken, boneless skinless breasts, chicken drumsticks, and party wings.

And, of course, seafood! Everything is wild-caught and sustainably harvested. Salmon is caught in its natural habitat in the pristine waters of Bristol Bay, Alaska. The scallops are caught in the cold waters of Georges Bank, lobsters are wild-caught by independent harvesters in the cold, clean waters of the North Atlantic, and cod and halibut are caught in the pristine waters of the Gulf of Alaska and the Bering Sea.

Using traditional, sustainable farming methods, this subscription gives you the satisfaction and confidence that the food you’re feeding to your family was raised and sourced responsibly!

Will you be subscribing to Butcher Box?


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *