BeautyFIX vs BOXYCHARM vs GLOSSYBOX October 2017 Battle of the $20+ Beauty Boxes!

Hello Subscription may earn compensation via links in this post. Read the full disclosure


It’s the BeautyFIX vs BOXYCHARM vs GLOSSYBOX showdown!


BOX BASICS: All four subscriptions are about $21-25 per month, so it’s easy to draw comparisons. All three of these beauty boxes also ship out 4-9 samples.

CUSTOMIZATION & VARIATION: There aren’t really any customization for these boxes. BeautyFIX typically ship the same box to everyone. BOXYCHARM & GLOSSYBOX ship variations to subscribers.

BeautyFIX ($24.95 per month!)

Typically skin & hair focused, with less makeup. A good mix of a couple full-sized products & sample sizes of pricier products.



Total Value: About $137

This box was one of my favorites of the year! With a couple full size high end skincare products plus cult fave Smith & Cult, and a Tocca fragrance, it was just truly fantastic!

Review: BeautyFIX October 2017 Review

See BeautyFIX spoilers + past BeautyFIX reviews or sign up for directory notifications when we post about this subscription!

BOXYCHARM ($21 per month!)

Typically includes a palette every month – whether it’s eyeshadow, concealer, contouring, or something else! This is the box for makeup lovers that want to do a full face!



Total Value: About $139

BOXYCHARM repeated the Dr. Brandt (it’s everywhere and we aren’t sad because it’s an amazing product!) and we scored the travel nail set. The tarteist lip paint is starting to feel a little dated (I think we are in a post matte-lip world with the launch of Fenty Beauty) but the Becca Prosecco Pop was fantastic!

Review:  BOXYCHARM October 2017 Review

See BOXYCHARM spoilers + past BOXYCHARM reviews or sign up for directory notifications when we post about this subscription!

GLOSSYBOX ($21 per month!)

Comes in a beautifully wrapped box which usually includes five deluxe-sized beauty products and wellness samples.


Lue By Jean Seo Erase Powder ($15)

Jafra Girl Squad Eau De Toilette deluxe spritzer

Vasanti Cosmetics Eyeshadow Brush ($21)

Clove + Hallow Lip Glaze!

Rituals Shower Foam in Happy Buddha ($15)

Total Value: About $85

Well, with the transition to The Hut Group GLOSSYBOX didn’t send us a box for October. Get it together Glossybox.  But also, my grandma used Jafra when I was growing up. Points for lip glaze instead of matte lip and the Rituals is a great item.

Review:  October 2017 GLOSSYBOX Review – NADA!

See GLOSSYBOX Spoilers + past GLOSSYBOX reviews or sign up for directory notifications when we post about this subscription!

Skincare winner – BeautyFIX. Makeup – BOXYCHARM. But you knew that already!

What did you think of the this month’s BeautyFIX, BOXYCHARM, and GLOSSYBOX? Did you have a favorite?


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

  • jaclyn

    the glossybox review/thoughts are not posted on this specific post, only beautyfix and boxycharm are shown

    • Brandy

      Oh ha. My assistant hid it because she didn’t know what we were doing with it. Unhid. GB has had some transition issues this month and didn’t send us a box. No box no review!