Blue Apron Review

Hello Subscription independently researches and reviews the best subscriptions and products. Things you buy through our links may earn us a commission.
Go to commentsNotification


Blue Apron is a meal/food/recipes/dinner subscription box. We have tried Blue Apron before (for Thanksgiving) and really enjoyed it. I cannot say the same thing about this time! I would give it 3 out of 5 stars. I recommend Plated or Hello Fresh instead!

First of all, Blue Apron hides your delivery notifications in an email about what you’re not receiving this week.

Whoops, missed that one. However, the meals looked decent and I really needed to review a regular box!


This box came with a lot of ice. I have never seen a meal service pack ice ON TOP of the delicate food….IMG_5552

And there’s a reason for it. Also I could barely lift this box. It arrived before my husband came home. Any more ice and it would have stayed on my floor. There were 3 four packs of ice. Overkill.IMG_5553

Tomatillos shouldn’t be mushy.

But there was a lot of food. That’s nice!

Buttermilk Fried Chicken Sliders with Homemade Pickles & Coleslaw – These were great. My husband hoped that was the end of shredding and matchsticking though. The recipes were ALL extremely time consuming. But the chicken was perfect and I enjoyed the pickled cukes & coleslaw combo on my hot fried chicken inside a potato roll. Even if they were completely squashed.


Grilled Steak Tacos with Roasted Salsa Verde & Black Quinoa “Pilaf” – I was so ready to dig into this meal. It ended up being a great appetizer. Fortunately the way the tomatillos were used their mushiness didn’t matter too much, but the black quinoa pilaf was terrible. I had to spit it out.  I’m not a fan of corn tortillas this way.IMG_5725

We repurposed them later into quesadillas but we tossed the pilaf. Also time consuming.IMG_5767

Crispy Sweet Corn & Pea Fritters with Rémoulade & with Pea Shoot Salad – I couldn’t eat the pea shoots. They weren’t my thing at all. My husband said they tasted better without the olive oil/lemon dressing. The amount of sauce was disappointing for the amount of fritters, but they were delicious. Once again, this was a very time consuming dish – shucking corn, cutting it off, shelling peas, etc. Frying up the fritters was pretty crazy with all those fresh veggies in the fritters too. My husband hadn’t realized I got a spatter screen. But good thing I did!

Two of the meals were really good, and one was really just a total fail. It probably took my husband an hour to prep each meal. Way too long.  Right now I wouldn’t recommend this unless you totally want to be shucking your peas and matchsticking each vegetable! Also there’s the mystery of the black quinoa. I like quinoa so….

Visit Blue Apron if you’d like to try it out yourself! You can also  see all the fresh food subscription boxes in my directory!


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

  • ashleywasnick

    we really love Meez Meals & Madison and Rayne… everything comes pre-sliced and pre-chopped… i literally have dinner ready in less than 20 minutes for each meal… much better than the prep time with Blue Apron or Plated… i would never be able to spend that kind of time prepping for a meal.

    • Brandy

      I need to try!!!!!!!

  • Diana Garza

    Uh….wow…that really sucks.
    My first box from them was a huge disappointment – I contacted them and they were going to give me a free box but, I decided to cancel and not even bother. Plated is my go-to never let’s me down meal subscription. I wish Hello Fresh delivered to my area so, I could try them out.

    • Brandy

      I contacted them about the squashed foods. They gave me a $10 credit although I’d already canceled. Totally meaningless and unsatisfactory. I love both Plated & HF. At least two of the meals were tasty. Alena messaged me and was like did he really matchstick those by hand? LOL he sure did. I love having him home for my dinner boxes. He’s the knife guy. Beyond the other issues the box just took too danged long to cook. The little flags on the sliders were cute though. I think another box would have sent coleslaw mix for the slaw. Oh yeah, he added mayo to it. There wasn’t enough. They show these great piles of stuff but the ingredients don’t match up. This was last week so I forgot to mention all of it.

      It’s too bad about HF. I think you would love the veggie box!!!